made any donations to the Conservatives before his delusions began to take hold in
1984, and the pattern of giving which began thereafter cannot in my judgment be
dismissed as no more than a reflection of his long-standing support for the party and
his admiration for Mrs Thatcher.
225.
The surviving letters which he sent to Mrs Thatcher, David Mellor and others make it
clear, in my view, that there was a definite connection between Bane’s deluded beliefs
and his relationship with the Conservative Party. Bane no doubt continued to espouse
conventional Conservative values as he had before his illness, but with the difference
that he now saw them as having a particular virtue in helping to defend the world, and
himself, against the conspiracy of dark forces. The link is made clear as early as
Bane’s first letter to Mrs Thatcher in December 1984, when he sent a cheque for
£5,000 “to fight the evil wicked Demons - SATANS and I am fully on your disposal”.
A similar attitude can be seen three years later, in his letter of 13 December 1987 to
David Mellor, where he refers to his nomadic existence and the dark forces
conspiracy, asks Mr Mellor to be his trustee and to recommend a trustworthy solicitor,
and says how important it is for him that his substantial wealth should not finish “in
the hands of destructive people – Satanic Monsters”. The same letter then goes on to
reaffirm, in extravagant language, Bane’s attachment to this country and his
admiration for Mrs Thatcher: “Our Prime Minister is the greatest Leader of the Free
World in the human [peacetime] history … God knows when we shall have again
such a unique and genius person”. The importance of these letters, and others like
them, is that they make explicit the link in Bane’s mind between his delusions and his
support for the Conservative Party and its values. In the light of this link, and the
expert evidence on the fixed nature of untreated delusions, I find it impossible to
attach much, if any, weight to other letters which, read in isolation, appear to endorse
traditional Conservative values and do not refer to the dark forces. An example of
such a letter is Bane’s letter of 18 April 1987 to the Right Hon. Norman Tebbit MP at
Conservative Central Office enclosing a donation of £3,000 for the next general
election, saying,
“Our Maggie is not only our dear PM – she is really today the
Leader of the Free World and we must support her
unconditionally to enable her Vision and Charisma to save and
protect our dignity, decency, democracy and freedom.”
226.
A similar point may be made in relation to Bane’s instructions to Mr Trower, and the
preparation of the 1988 and 1989 Wills. To judge from Mr Trower’s attendance note,
Bane’s original instructions to him at their first meeting were on the face of it entirely
rational. However, Mr Trower can have been in no doubt that Bane suffered from
some form of mental illness once he saw some of the letters enclosed with Bane’s
letter to him of 16 June 1988; and some of Bane’s subsequent letters to Mr Trower,
including in particular his letter of 19 December 1988, can only be described as
totally deranged. Mr Trower’s reaction to these letters seems to have been one of
embarrassed silence. There is no indication that he advised Bane to seek psychiatric
help, nor did he suggest that the 1988 and 1989 Wills should be witnessed and
approved by a medical practitioner who had satisfied himself as to Bane’s capacity
and understanding and made a record of his examination and findings (the so-called
“golden rule” referred to by the Court of Appeal in Sharp v Adam at paragraph [27]).
My strong impression is that Mr Trower turned a blind eye to the problem, and
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents