REASONS
Introduction
1. This Decision relates to an Appeal brought by the Appellant pursuant to
section 57 Freedom of Information Act 2000. It is in respect of a decision
notice issued by the Information Commissioner and concerns a request for
information made to the University of Essex.
2. References to page numbers in this Decision are to an open bundle provided
for the Appeal of 1,669 pages. If a reference is to one of the many documents
provided but not included in that bundle the reference is to the internal
numbering of that document itself.
3. We recognise that notwithstanding the Senior President of Tribunals Practice
Direction of the 4 June 2024 this Decision is lengthy. This is because we
considered the amount of content necessary to deal with the Appeal and the
many points raised. However what follows is a summary of the submissions,
evidence and our view of the law. It does not seek to provide every step of our
reasoning. The absence of a reference by us to any specific submission or
evidence does not mean it has not been considered.
4. The Appeal was first considered by the Tribunal on 4 March 2024. Due to the
number of issues raised and the amount of material provided we considered it
necessary and appropriate and in compliance with the overriding objective (in
particular rule 2(2)(a) 2009 Rules) to reconvene on 20 May 2024 to continue our
consideration of this matter.
5. In this Decision we have adopted the following definitions.
Freedom of Information Act 2000
FOIA
Data Protection Act 2018
DPA
United Kingdom General Data Protection Regulation
GDPR
The Tribunal Procedure (First -Tier Tribunal) (General Regulatory Chamber)
Rules 2009
2009 Rules
Alan David Sokal
the Appellant
The Information Commissioner
the IC
University of Essex
UoE
Decision Notice
the DN
The Grounds of Appeal
the GoA
Report commissioned by UoE and prepared by Akua Reindorf KC
the Report
2