MR JUSTICE JOHNSON
Approved Judgment
Hegab v Spectator
Submissions
81.
Mark Henderson, for the claimant, submits that both parties are responsible for all
publications of the article, which bears the following meaning:
“The Claimant incited religious/racial hatred against the Hindu
community, stirring up a Muslim mob in a UK city to violently
target Hindus by attacking, disparaging, and dehumanising
Hindus qua Hindus, including by ridiculing Hindus for their
belief in reincarnation and describing them as pathetic, weak
and cowardly in comparison to whom he would rather be an
animal.”
He says that the evidence shows that the publication has caused serious harm to the
claimant’s reputation, and that the defendants have not proved that it is substantially
true. He argues that it is obviously untrue, as can be seen by a comparison of the
article with the words spoken by the claimant which referred to the Hindutva and
made no reference to Hindus. It follows that the article is inaccurate, so if the claimant
fails in his libel claim on the basis of reference or serious harm, he must nonetheless
succeed in his data protection claim.
82.
Greg Callus, for the first defendant, and William Bennett KC, for the second
defendant, submit that the article bears the following meaning:
“Mohammed Hijab is a street agitator who last year whipped up
a mob with inflammatory language at an anti-Israel protest and
then cropped up during recent disturbances between Hindus
and Muslims in Leicester to whip up his followers including by
ridiculing Hindus for their belief in re-incarnation and
describing Hindus as pathetic, weak and cowardly in
comparison to whom he would rather be an animal.”
83.
They do not accept that the article sufficiently identifies the claimant, pointing to the
different spelling of the name and the absence of a pleaded case on a reference
innuendo. They say that the claimant’s evidence in respect of harm is not credible and
should be rejected, so the claim in libel must fail. The second defendant (but not the
first defendant) accepts that there was a mistake in the article insofar as it attributes to
the claimant a reference to “Hindus” whereas he actually said “the Hindutva”.
Irrespective of that possible mistake, both defendants say that the defamatory
imputation conveyed by the article is, on the evidence, substantially true.
Accordingly, they say that both the libel and data protection claims must be
dismissed. The first defendant also says that the claim falls to be struck out for want
of proper disclosure.
Responsibility for publication
84.
The second defendant is the author of the article, which he intended for publication.
The first defendant published the article in print and on its website. It is therefore
common ground that both defendants are responsible for the print and website
publications (and republications) of the article.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents