MR JUSTICE JOHNSON
Approved Judgment
Hegab v Spectator
103.
Seventh, the claimant relies on what he says is a death-threat. That is contained in an
Instagram message which is undated. Nothing in the Instagram message references
the article. It may have been written in response to the claimant’s video of his speech,
or something else. There is no evidence that the article caused the death-threat to be
made.
104.
It follows that the claim in defamation must be dismissed.
Truth
105.
It is, accordingly, not necessary to address the truth defence, but I do so, briefly, for
completeness.
106.
The resolution of the truth defence, in the context of the present case, requires an
objective assessment of what the claimant was doing and what he said. This is not
quite the same exercise as is involved in the determination of the meaning of the
article. It is not necessary to have recourse to the hypothetical reasonable listener to
his speech, or to divine a single meaning of the speech. What is required is to
determine, objectively, what it is the claimant did and, in the light of that, to decide
whether the defamatory imputation conveyed by the article is substantially true.
107.
The description of the claimant as a “street agitator who has whipped up a mob on
London’s streets” and as someone who “addressed an anti-Israel protest in
inflammatory terms” is an accurate description of what the claimant is seen to do at
the rally for Israel.
108.
The claimant’s fundamental complaint is that it was completely wrong for the second
defendant to say that the claimant had ridiculed Hindus. It is true that he did not use
the word Hindus. However, it is common ground that he was talking about the
opposing group of men who were involved in the disturbances. Once the claimant’s
concept of non-Hindu Hindutva is rejected as an unreal construct, everyone who was
present (including the claimant) understood that group to be largely, if not
overwhelmingly, composed of Hindu men. It was them that he was ridiculing. He did
so not by picking on a feature that defines the Hindutva but instead by picking on an
aspect of Hinduism (reincarnation), after first asserting the superiority of Islam (“we
got the truth”). He, in terms, described them (that is, the Hindu men) as “pathetic,
weak and cowardly” such that he would “rather be an animal.” That speech, to a large
group of excitable and engaged masked young men, exacerbated the tensions that had
spilled over into serious public disorder the previous day.
109.
Even if it were necessary to determine what the claimant subjectively intended to do
(and it is not), the truth defence would be established. The claimant knew exactly
what he was doing. He chose his words deliberately. He did so in a way that left him
room to put forward “innocent” explanations, but those explanations do not withstand
scrutiny.
110.
It follows that even if the claimant had succeeded in showing that he had suffered
serious reputational harm as a result of the article, the claim would fall to be
dismissed because the defendants have established that the defamatory imputation
conveyed by the article is substantially true.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents