MR JUSTICE JOHNSON
Approved Judgment
Hegab v Spectator
85.
The particulars of claim also rely on publication of the article by the second defendant
on his website. The second defendant is not employed by the first defendant and the
claimant does not allege that the first defendant is vicariously liable for the conduct of
the second defendant. It follows that the first defendant is not responsible for any
publication of the article by the second defendant in respect of which the first
defendant took no part. Conversely, to the extent to which the second defendant
provided links to the first defendant’s website publication of the article, both
defendants are responsible for the publications that took place when users clicked on
those links.
86.
The claimant has not sued on the app version of the article, so it is unnecessary to
consider that version further.
Meaning and reference
87.
I read the article, before reading the other documents in the case, in advance of the
pre-trial review. I recorded the meaning that I considered was conveyed by it. I have
reviewed that meaning in the light of the parties’ proposed meanings, and their
respective submissions. There are a number of common elements. The final passage
of both parties’ proposed meanings is the same. It derives directly from the words of
the article. I am content to adopt it.
88.
There are aspects of the claimant’s meaning that I do not consider are conveyed by
the article. First, the suggestion that the claimant incited racial/religious hatred and
stirred up a mob to violently target Hindus goes a little (albeit not far) beyond the
meaning conveyed by the article. Second, the article does not state that the claimant
“dehumanised” Hindus. The reference to “animal” is part of the ridiculing of
reincarnation. It does not, in itself, dehumanise Hindus. Nor does anything else in the
article convey that this is what the claimant did. Third, although I understand what is
meant by “Hindus qua Hindus”, and I accept that the article does attribute to the
claimant language that disparages a central tenet of Hinduism, that is sufficiently
captured by the agreed final part of the meaning. The “Hindus qua Hindus” provides
an additional technical gloss which owes more to the dispute on truth than it does to
the meaning conveyed by the article. On the other hand, whilst the court cannot
ultimately find the defendants liable in respect of a defamatory imputation that is not
alleged by the claimant, the claimant’s proposed meaning does not capture an
important aspect of the meaning conveyed by the article: that the claimant was a street
agitator who had whipped up a mob in London and had addressed an anti-Israel
protest with inflammatory language. I appreciate that the claimant does not advance a
distinct complaint about this part of the article, but it is artificial to divorce what was
said about the claimant’s activities in Leicester from its immediate context.
89.
The defendants’ meaning seems to me fairly to reflect some of the meaning conveyed
by the article, but it does not go quite far enough. Although I do not accept that the
article quite conveys the meaning that the claimant stirred up a Muslim mob to
violently target Hindus, it does go further than simply suggesting that the claimant
ridiculed reincarnation. The early part of the article (talking about the disturbances
between Muslims and Hindus), the section that refers to the claimant (whipping up a
mob, ridiculing reincarnation), and the section that immediately follows (“Soon both
sides were accusing the other of attacking their places of worship. Crowds of
hundreds faced off…”) all form part of a linked and coherent narrative. What is
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents