MR JUSTICE JOHNSON
Approved Judgment
Hegab v Spectator
Data Protection claim
111.
Mr Henderson agreed that if the defendants successfully establish that the article’s
defamatory imputation is substantially true, then the data protection claim cannot be
sustained. That is because if the defamatory imputation is substantially true, there is
no material inaccuracy in the article that can found such a claim. Accordingly, the
data protection claim is dismissed.
Strike out
112.
The claim must be dismissed on the merits. It is not therefore necessary to address Mr
Callus’ alternative argument that the claim should be struck out. I prefer not to do so.
It is therefore unnecessary to address a submission advanced by Mr Henderson that a
separate hearing is required to determine the strike out application.
Outcome
113.
The defendants are each responsible for the article, which conveys the following
meaning:
“The claimant is a street agitator who has whipped up a mob on
London’s streets, addressed an anti-Israel protest in
inflammatory terms, and exacerbated frayed tensions (which
had already spilled over into public disorder) between Muslim
and Hindu communities in Leicester by whipping up his
Muslim followers including by ridiculing Hindus for their
belief in re-incarnation and describing Hindus as pathetic, weak
and cowardly in comparison to whom he would rather be an
animal.”
That meaning is a statement of fact which is defamatory of the claimant at common
law. The publication has not caused, and is not now likely to cause, serious harm to
the claimant’s reputation. In any event, it is substantially true, and it is not materially
inaccurate. The claims are, accordingly, dismissed.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents