MR JUSTICE JOHNSON
Approved Judgment
Hegab v Spectator
missing from the defendants’ meaning is a recognition of that, and in particular
recognition of the alleged consequences of the claimant’s actions as conveyed by the
article. I do not consider that the article suggests that the claimant directly and solely
caused the events that followed, but it does suggest that his speech was inflammatory
and that it exacerbated existing tensions between opposing groups that had already
spilled over into public disorder. That is at the core of the defamatory imputation that
is conveyed by the article. I do not consider that the article conveyed a distinct
meaning as to whether those tensions were based on race or religion. I agree with a
submission advanced by Mr Henderson that there is no bright line between
disparagement of Hindus as an ethnic group or as a religious group or as an
ethnoreligious group. The key point is that the article conveys that the claimant was a
street agitator who was whipping up ill-feeling by one community towards another, in
circumstances where tensions were already frayed and had spilled over into public
disorder.
90.
The article clearly refers to the claimant. It does so by reference to his name.
Although it uses a different transliteration from his legal name, it is a version of his
name that is used by the claimant in his voluminous social media output. The
reference to him would be apparent to anybody acquainted with him.
91.
I find that the article conveys the following meaning:
“The claimant is a street agitator who has whipped up a mob on
London’s streets, addressed an anti-Israel protest in
inflammatory terms, and exacerbated frayed tensions (which
had already spilled over into public disorder) between Muslim
and Hindu communities in Leicester by whipping up his
Muslim followers including by ridiculing Hindus for their
belief in re-incarnation and describing Hindus as pathetic, weak
and cowardly in comparison to whom he would rather be an
animal.”
92.
This is a statement of fact which is defamatory of the claimant at common law.
93.
It is unnecessary to address Mr Callus’ submission that there are contexts in which it
is not defamatory to accuse someone of ridiculing reincarnation. Here, as Mr
Henderson correctly points out, the allegations levelled at the claimant are very far
from doctrinal religious disputes or a sketch in a comedy club. The allegation is not
simply that the claimant ridiculed Hindus, but that he did this as a device to whip up
his Muslim followers and thereby exacerbate existing frayed tensions (which had
already spilled over into public disorder) between two communities. That plainly is
defamatory at common law.
94.
I do not consider that it is necessary to resolve arguments as to whether the
defamatory meaning amounts to one, or more than one, imputation, or whether it is
necessary separately to identify a defamatory sting, or stings, or a common sting,
associated with each imputation. The meaning is as set out above. Whether that
meaning is properly analysed as containing one or more than one imputation, or sting,
the issue under section 2 of the 2013 Act is whether the imputation(s) are substantially
true.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents