190.
The Claimant’s “Advice” remains widely accessible on the internet and has not been
publicly qualified or disavowed by him.
(3) DEVIANT GROUPS SPEECH (2009)
191.
The BBC rely upon a speech given by the Claimant on 31 st May 2009 at LIC as part of
LIC’s four-part “Deviant Groups” series of seminars which focussed on ‘deviant’
groups within the Muslim community. The primary topics covered were hakimiyyah
(dominion/authority) and jihad. The experts agreed that the context of the talk would
have been a semi-formal, mosque-based teaching event in the form of a teacher-led
discussion or question-and-answer session with relatively Islamically-informed
participants, probably of a Salafi-Islamic persuasion.
Preliminary observations
192.
I make the following preliminary observations on the speech. First, it is clear the
speech was not simply delivered off-the-cuff, but was carefully prepared. As the
Claimant accepted in cross-examination, he discussed the speech in advance with a
teacher at the Young Muslim Academy at LIC, Brother Ilyas Townsend, who was
involved with the da’wah projects (call or spreading the word of Islam, proselytising
and persuading others to join Islam) and who was to join him on the podium. They
discussed and decided the topic for the meeting, neo-Salafism, the question-andanswer
format and the themes to be raised and discussed, which included the meaning of
jihad.
193.
Second, the speech or lecture was delivered at a mosque, in a context which Professor
Gleave accepted was ‘primarily educational’, before an engaged Muslim audience,
who can be assumed to have been present because they were interested in learning
more about Islam and “Deviant Groups” from the Chief Imam of LIC. The audience
included young, impressionable men who were about to go off to play football
together for the LIC Football Club in the Catford Power League. When dealing with
such sensitive issues as jihad before such an audience, in my view, it was incumbent
upon any Imam to take the very greatest care with the language used.
194.
Third, the speech was clearly intended for wider dissemination. It was uploaded onto
LIC’s website by Brother Ilyas Townsend, one of whose roles was to keep the mosque
website (www.lewishamislamiccentre.com) updated. The Claimant claims not to have
been aware of the speech going up onto the website at the time but accepts being
aware of Brother Ilyas Townsend’s role. I have no doubt that the Claimant expected
and intended this speech to go up on the website and to remain there for a wider
audience for a significant period, as with many of his formal speeches and lectures.
The LIC website was one of his prime teaching tools as Chief Imam.
Text of key sections of the speech
195.
The teachings of the Salafi-Wahabi scholar, Sheikh Abdul Aziz bin Baz, feature
heavily in the Claimant’s speech. Sheikh bin Baz was the Grand Mufti of Saudi
Arabia in the 1990s and a highly significant religious figure in the development and
prominence of Salafi-Wahabi Islam in the 20th century (see further below).
196.
I set out below the text of eleven key sections of the Claimant’s DEVIANT GROUPS
SPEECH (2009). In the first section, the Claimant quotes Sheikh bin Baz’s
43
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents